عطر واحد فقط المناسب وباقي 4 عطور جودته غير مقبوله
4 Stars- Good
I have to be frank with you: the fragrances did not meet my expectations or my standards.
I purchased 18 different scents, most of which I know very well in their original versions. After testing them, I would say that, in my opinion, they are generally only around 50–75% close to the originals, and unfortunately none of them reached the 90% level I was expecting.
More importantly, I noticed something common across all of the fragrances: there seems to be a certain underlying DNA or ingredient/accord that you are using across your creations, and I personally find this common element unpleasant. Even when the fragrance is otherwise reasonably close to the original, this shared DNA changes the overall smell and prevents it from smelling natural or convincing to my nose.
So, unfortunately, these fragrances are not for me and do not reach my personal standard. I believe you still have some way to go before reaching the level of accuracy and quality I am looking for.
I say this with respect because I know how difficult it is to reproduce a fragrance properly, and I would rather give you honest feedback than simply say that I didn't like them.
For comparison, look at the work of Despasito. Their fragrances, for example Neroli Blanche, are exceptionally well made. In fact, I personally prefer their Neroli Blanche to the original LV Imagination. Their other products are also very well executed, with a quality of ingredients and a finish that I find much more convincing.
I wish you the best of luck, and I hope you continue improving. I am giving you this feedback because I believe you have the potential to get much closer to the originals.
5 Stars- Very Good
